Part of the btw project. Daily poetry and other forms of writing.

Friday, November 10, 2006

Examples of our feedback.

Dear ******,

Your poetry shows a natural sense of how not only words but structure in poetry can be manipulated. This is particularly effective in ‘Pain’ and ‘Don’t’ (also two of your strongest pieces). You tackle fairly universal topics, but there are subtleties here that are unique. Your use of language is, sometimes, breathtaking. There are some lines that are truly excellent, as I will discuss.

Recognize:

What I liked:

You’ve used repetition and parallelism well, and some lines in this context are very effective (“The broken of my back”). This is a very typically ‘teenage’ subject, as I’ve mentioned above, yet you have given it an interesting subtlety. “the softness of my tongue” offers a hint of something not sexual, but deeper than teen romance. That is an excellent line.

Suggestions:

Stay away from clichéd phrases. Not to suggest that your work is clichéd, but you’ve done so well with the unconventional (as I quoted above) that “We could dance the whole night through” doesn’t do the poem justice. Some lines can be a little awkward, e.g. “breath of my mouth”, “pitter”

In my experience, when using a repetitive structure it is best to keep poetry short. Unless there is a message or a concluding stanza or line that is tremendous, breathtaking, fantastic, etc. being crisp and concise works better.

What I would suggest doing is, perhaps, shortening the poem and working on a stronger last line. Concentrate on the flow of the piece – perhaps start with very ‘soft’ imagery and then move into the deeper, more intense stuff (“broken of my back…softness of my tongue”).

-------------------

Dear *******,

Your '-------' piece was interesting, because you’ve chosen a topic that’s unique and sensitive. There are some lines that I think are extremely powerful, which I’ll talk about now:

The imagery and symbolism here is particularly effective. “The sun seeping through my window that’s wrapped in warmth and love. The sun that I try to ignore.” You’ve used the sun as a sort of motif throughout the piece, established as something he wants but can’t have, and is forced to avoid. “My options are running out while I’m running out of air, drowning in the covers of my blankets and the heavy sleep air.” I like the repetition of “air”; it gives a sense of drowsiness or ‘thickness’. Was that intentional? If so, it was very nice. The last part of the sentence “Heavy sleep air” is an excellent image – it gives off that sense of stuffiness, loneliness, the feeling when you’ve woken up after a bad nights sleep. “In the early morning, the few cars that go, go fast, past my quarters. Maybe they’re trying to avoid living the night as well” This is wonderful personification. There’s a poem called “Merritt Parkway” by Denise Levertov that reminds me of that, I’ll add that poem on the bottom. The image of cars in the morning is very effective- they’re speeding away, trying to escape something. “. Even my strong, favourite songs” another example of good writing. The way you use “strong” to describe the songs is unexpected yet… its sounds good! The word ‘sinister’ also personifies the music well; perhaps you could expand on that?


We talked about suggestions of how you could improve. You have a knack for creating these phrases (like the ones quoted above) that are very powerful, which show what the man feels like, instead of just saying it. When he talks about the cars you don’t have to say he’s lonely or that he wants to escape, in that one beautiful images you’ve captured it. Because of this, you don’t need a lot of the ‘explanation sentences’ that you use. When writing short pieces like this, concentrate on the atmosphere, of capturing the feeling of what you’re trying to describe. The story will tell itself.

My idea was to cut down on words, cut this mini-story into a paragraph by keeping all the very intense imagery, and removing the superfluous. Another idea was to make it a poem. You can take a lot of liberties with poetry – lines don’t have to flow or make sense as long as the reader leaves with the sense of what you’re trying to say. I’ve attached a word document with the highlighted lines that would be good in a poem – though of course the final decision is up to you. Take this advice with a pinch of salt.

This is a good piece where a sense of mystery would work. For example, where you talk about how everyone is afraid of laugh, you don’t have to say it’s because they are afraid of waking the nightworker up. Just leave it open, and let the reader figure it out.

So: cutting it down, more showing-not-telling. That’s our advice, and if you work on this piece I really think it could be breathtaking, and would definitely make it on to our site. You’ve taken a subject that is definitely not clichéd or typically teenager-ish which says a lot for your perceptiveness. There’s also a social message here, which (in a literary sense) gives it a lot more substance.

When you’re revising, take a minute to sit down with a thesaurus and a pen and paper and brainstorm words that describe the atmosphere, tone and mood you’re trying to establish. Try to use those words, or images that conjure them in your mind. Work on key metaphors like the cars and the sun, make them subtle but expand on them. The personification of the cars has a lot of potential.

Below is the poem I was talking about, by Levertov. When I read your piece, I envisage the potential for something like “Merritt Parkway”. Look how she has managed to keep the pace flowing, the way she doesn’t describe every detail and lets the reader kind of figure out for themselves- where the cars are going, who the people are, why she has chosen to write about them, what she’s saying about human society.


Merritt Parkway

by Denise Levertov

As if it were

forever that they move, that we

keep moving—

Under a wan sky where

as the lights went on a star

pierced the haze & now

follows steadily

a constant

above our six lanes

the dreamlike continuum…

And the people—ourselves!

the humans from inside the

cars apparent

only at gasoline stops

unsure,

eyeing each other

drink coffee hastily at the

slot machines & hurry

back to the cars

vanish

into them forever, to

keep moving—

Houses now & then beyond the

sealed road, the trees/tress, bushes

passing by, passing

the cars that

keep moving ahead of

us, past us, pressing behind us

and

over left, those that come

toward us shining too brightly

moving relentlessly

in six lanes, gliding

north & south, speeding with

a slurred sound—

As for more recommended reading, I’ll include some poems that, hopefully, you’ll like...

********